Thinking about redesigning your website? Before you start rebuilding pages, choosing new fonts, and rethinking your entire color palette, consider this:
What if you don't actually need a redesign?
Sometimes a few small changes can make a bigger difference than starting over. Other times, your business has evolved so much that the website you built a few years ago simply doesn't fit anymore.
The trick is knowing the difference.
Three ways to give your website a new direction
Not every website change deserves to be called a redesign. I think there are three levels worth understanding.
1. Website update: Keep things current
A basic update is the everyday work that keeps your website useful and accurate.
Adding testimonials, updating prices, publishing blog posts, and replacing outdated photos all fall into this category.
If your website still represents your business and does what you need it to do, regular updates might be all you need.
2. Website refresh: Improve what you've already built
A refresh is about changing how your business is presented without rebuilding the foundation of your website.
Maybe your branding has evolved. Maybe your messaging could be clearer. Maybe you've developed a new creative style and you're ready for your website to reflect it.
A refresh could mean updating your colors, reworking homepage sections, refining calls to action, or simplifying your navigation.
You get the excitement of something new without starting from scratch.
3. Website redesign: Rethink the foundation
A redesign makes sense when the website itself no longer supports the business behind it.
Maybe you're targeting a different audience, changing your services, or moving in an entirely new direction.
At that point, you might need to reconsider what pages you have, how information is organized, and what you want visitors to do.
That's more than a visual update. That's rethinking how your website works for your business.
And if you're changing URLs or removing content, remember to plan your redirects and protect any valuable search traffic you've already earned.
Changing your website doesn't mean the original design failed
I redesigned Inside the Square twice this year.
The first redesign was about removing hundreds of outdated tutorials and simplifying my website. The second was about putting my personality back into the design and creating something that reflected the direction I wanted my business to go.
Both versions were necessary.
And that's something I think we forget when talking about website redesigns.
A website that worked beautifully three years ago isn't a failure just because you need something different today.
You're allowed to change your mind. You're allowed to experiment. And you're allowed to let go of designs and content you worked hard to create.
But you're also allowed to keep what works.
There's no expiration date on good design, and a bigger change isn't automatically a better one.
So, does your website really need a redesign?
Maybe! But don't assume that starting over is always the answer.
Your website should support the business you're building, not just represent the business you've built.
In episode 110 of Think Inside the Square, I'm sharing the story behind my two redesigns, why creative people get so attached to their work, and why changing your website can be a very good thing.
Listen to Episode 110: Does Your Website Need a Redesign? Maybe Not.
And if you're not sure what your Squarespace website needs next, my Website Review & Action Plan can help you figure out what's worth changing and what you should leave alone.
Your website isn't set in stone. Have fun making it yours!
-
This transcript was automatically generated by Descript AI and. may contain errors.
[00:00:00] I redesigned my website twice this year, and honestly, I'm really glad I did. Yes, both times. The first redesign was about removing old and outdated content that just wasn't helping anyone anymore. I cleaned everything up, I reorganized my resources, and I launched a much simpler version of Inside the Square.
[00:00:19] And it was fine, but it was kinda boring. I had spent so much time figuring out what needed to go that I hadn't really thought about what I wanted to replace it with. So, a few months later, I launched my redesign of the redesign, and what I have now is a site I am very proud of. I made a real effort to put personality back into my work.
[00:00:40] I made it nostalgic for a more angsty, loud, and unapologetic version of me. Now, you might think that two redesigns in one year sounds like a lot of unnecessary work, and some of it really felt like it was. But I genuinely needed both versions to get to what I have today,
[00:00:58] And that got me thinking about something I see far too often, especially when people invest a lot of time and money into their websites. We treat them like they're finished, like we spent all this time designing the perfect homepage, choosing the perfect color palette, organizing the navigation with just the right number of links, and once it's all published, that's it.
[00:01:19] We're done. Don't touch it. Don't move anything. It's perfect as is. But here's the thing, your website should not be set in stone. It's not some priceless artifact that you're supposed to preserve exactly the way it looked on launch day. For a lot of us, a website is a working part of a business, and if your business changes, your website needs to change too.
[00:01:41] I'm Becca from Inside the Square, and in this episode of Think Inside the Square, I'm gonna talk about why it's okay to let go of designs and content that you once loved, and how to recognize whether your website needs a few updates, a refresh, or an entirely new design.
[00:01:56] Because sometimes the best thing you can do for your website is let go of what it used to be. Now, a quick disclaimer before we get into it, Squarespace is a trademark of Squarespace Incorporated. This podcast is not affiliated with or endorsed by Squarespace Incorporated. And for a transcript of this episode, along with the links to any resources I'll mention, visit insidethesquare.co/podcast.
[00:02:17] All right, let's get into it. I want you to think about the last time you got a really good photo of yourself taken. Maybe it was a professional headshot for your website, maybe it was a family portrait, or maybe it was just a really good selfie that you ended up using as your profile picture for way too long.
[00:02:36] Now, when it was taken, the photo looked like you. Obviously, it's a photograph. But a few years later, maybe you got a different haircut, or you started to wear a different style of clothes, or maybe you finally ditched that solid black eyeliner. Whatever it is, you changed. But that photo you are still using, it's not necessarily bad, it's just not current anymore.
[00:02:56] And your website works the exact same way. When you built it, it represented your business at that moment. The services you offered, the customers you wanted to attract, the things you wanted people to know about you was right there on the page. It was probably the absolutely perfect version of your business at that moment in time.
[00:03:14] But somewhere along the way, some of those things have probably changed. Maybe you started your business as a freelancer, and now you've got a small team. Or maybe you were offering a dozen different services, and now you've narrowed a focus on just a few things that you're really good at. Or maybe you've been doing the same kind of work for years, and you realize that's not what you want to spend the rest of your career doing, and that is okay.
[00:03:38] I think that sometimes we get so attached to the businesses that we've built, we forget that we're allowed to change our minds about what we want to do with them. My own business and my own website is a perfect example of that. For years, I built Inside the Square around teaching people how to use Squarespace in creative ways, especially with custom code.
[00:03:59] I made hundreds of tutorials. I sold code resources and workshops. I built an entire business around helping people do things with Squarespace that they didn't necessarily know were possible, and I loved it. But over the last few years, Squarespace has changed. All right, the entire internet has changed, if we're being honest.
[00:04:20] Some of the things that I used to teach are now built-in Squarespace features. A lot of my old tutorials were showing people an interface that didn't exist anymore I realized that the work I wanted to spend my time doing has changed. Now, I still love Squarespace.
[00:04:34] I still love making creative websites. But I don't want to spend the next decade playing catch up for every new feature and program change that they release. I'm ready for something different, and my website needed to reflect that. So the first redesign, that was about changing things up, removing outdated content and reorganizing my resources.
[00:04:53] I wanted to make sure that people could find information that was still useful, but remove the stuff that wasn't. And it was a big project There were hundreds of blog posts to go through, and by the time I finished, I was honestly exhausted. So I launched a much simpler version of that website and gave myself some time to figure out what was next.
[00:05:12] it was a little nerve-wracking putting out something kind of subpar for a while, especially so publicly, but I needed to take time to get really clear about the work that I wanted to do, the people I wanted to work with, and I really needed to have a much better understanding of what I wanted my business to be before I redesigned my website to match it.
[00:05:32] I'm really glad that I took that extra time, and I'm really glad that I decided to do a full redesign. In this latest version, I went for kind of a ninetys zine style aesthetic, and it honestly makes me very happy.
[00:05:45] I've got some hand-drawn doodles, crumpled paper textures that I literally made in my kitchen with the help of my almost one-year-old, and I made all kinds of just little weird design details that don't really fit the mold. This website finally feels like me. But more importantly, this website reflects the business I'm building now.
[00:06:05] A website shouldn't just represent the business you've built. It should support the business you're building. Now, sometimes getting there means being willing to let go of the things that used to work.
[00:06:16] I think this is where a lot of us creative people get stuck. It's where I get stuck. I get really attached to the things that I make. I put a lot of work into the previous versions of my website. I remember the decisions I made and how excited I was about all the little details that I spent way too much time perfecting.
[00:06:35] I was proud of what I created,
[00:06:37] But being proud of something doesn't mean you have to keep using it forever. Just because something took a lot of time and effort to create doesn't mean that it needs to be a permanent part of your business. Maybe your website did exactly what it needed to do for the last three years, but that doesn't mean it needs to stay the same forever.
[00:06:55] And honestly, I don't think it should. Sometimes the website doesn't even need to change because your business changed. Sometimes you just have a better idea. You learned something new, you further developed your style, or just found a more interesting way to talk about what you do. I think you should give yourself permission to explore those ideas too.
[00:07:13] Not every creative decision has to be justified by some enormous business transformation. Sometimes you just wanna try something different, and that's the fun part about having a website that you can control. You can experiment. You can try new things. Test out a couple of headlines. Change your call to action every other day if you feel like it
[00:07:33] And that brings me to the last point I wanna make in this episode. I don't think that every website really does need a full redesign. In fact, I think in our industry, we throw around that word a little too casually. Sometimes a few small changes can make a much bigger difference than rebuilding the entire thing.
[00:07:52] I think there are three levels of website changes worth understanding. The first is a basic update. This is the everyday stuff. You're gonna add a testimonial, publish a new blog post, maybe update your prices. These little updates that keep your website accurate and useful, that's just a basic update. And honestly, everyone with a website should be doing some form of basic updates pretty regularly.
[00:08:16] So that's level one. Now, the second level is what I like to call a website refresh. This is where your business is fundamentally the same, like the goal of your website is the same as it was before, but the way you're presenting it could use some work. Maybe your branding has evolved, or you got better photos, your messaging is clearer, or you wanna test a different style of messaging now.
[00:08:39] A refresh is about improving what's already there You don't tear the entire thing apart, you're just making some changes about the way your business is presented. Honestly, I think refreshes are really fun projects.
[00:08:53] You get the excitement of trying something new without having to completely rebuild your entire website from scratch, And you don't have to worry about things like URL mapping for old redirects.
[00:09:03] Refreshes are fun and a lot less stressful. But we do have that third level, the actual redesign, when the foundation itself needs to change. If you're going to serve an entirely different audience or change your business model like I did, that's when it's time to do a redesign.
[00:09:21] A redesign is when you need to rethink more than just how the site looks. You might need to change how the content is organized, what pages exist, how people navigate the site, what the goal of the site is, what you're asking visitors to do.
[00:09:34] If you've got to change that, that's a redesign. And sometimes that is absolutely the right thing to do. But what I really want to emphasize and wrap this episode up with is the idea that A redesign isn't automatically better than an update. Sometimes rewriting three sentences on your homepage can have a way bigger impact than rebuilding the entire site.
[00:09:54] And a website that is five years old isn't automatically worse than one that was just launched yesterday. There's no expiration date on good design. What matters is whether or not your website is still doing what you need it to do. So that's the big idea I want you to take away from today's episode.
[00:10:10] Your website is allowed to change. It's not there to preserve the business that you had when you created it. It's there to help you build the business that you want to have next. Now, I'm curious where your website falls on those three levels. Do you feel like you're in a good place doing basic updates?
[00:10:26] Are you thinking about a refresh, maybe just changing up the messaging a bit or the style? Or are you ready to do what I did and throw the whole thing away and start over? I would love to hear from you. Let me know in the comments which one of those three levels best describes where you're at with your website right now, or send me an email, hello@insidethesquare.co.
[00:10:45] I'm Becca from Inside the Square. Thank you so much for tuning into episode 110 of Think Inside the Square. If you enjoyed it, give it a like and share it with a friend, but most importantly, have fun with your website. Bye for now.
Other Episodes You Might Enjoy
Episode 106: I Redesigned My Website Again: The SEO Checklist Before You Launch
Planning a full redesign? Here's how to handle your URLs, redirects, and SEO so your new site doesn't lose the search visibility you've already earned.
Episode 74: 15-Minute Website Improvements That Make a Big Impact
Don't need a complete redesign? Start with small, practical changes that can make your website more effective.
Episode 91: Five Things I'm Judging About Every Website I See
Five things to review on your website, including homepage messaging, mobile layouts, typography, and buttons. Great for anyone considering a refresh.
Episode 105: Good Design Advice That Makes Bad Websites
For designers who want to make more intentional decisions, this episode challenges common design rules and explains why context matters more than following trends.